Parents face the daunting task of making numerous decisions for their children, even when it comes to something as seemingly harmless as their sleep habits. Sleep training offers a wide range of approaches and opinions. Our intention is not to judge whether you choose to sleep train or not, but rather to provide you with the knowledge to make the best decision for your child’s sleep.
Is it possible to sleep train one-year-old children?
Absolutely! If you have a baby who is 12 months or older, sleep training can be an option to address sleep issues related to sleep onset associations, such as when a baby relies on being held, rocked, or fed to fall asleep. After the age of 4 months, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) suggests placing your baby in their sleep space while they are still drowsy but not fully asleep. This helps them learn to fall asleep independently, leading to fewer nighttime wakings and more restful sleep for the entire family.
It sounds straightforward enough, doesn’t it? However, in reality, transitioning from the practice of rocking, holding, or feeding your baby to sleep to having them fall asleep on their own can be challenging. If you decide to attempt sleep training, there are various techniques available that can assist you. You can choose a method that suits your preferences and aligns with your baby’s personality, whether you prefer a faster or slower approach. Ultimately, it is up to you to determine if sleep training is the right fit for your family.
How long does it take to sleep train a one-year-old or older?
The timeframe for seeing results can vary, ranging from a few days to several weeks. The duration depends on the sleep training method you choose, your objectives, and your child’s temperament. Typically, if you utilize a gradual or total extinction technique, you can expect to observe some progress after 3 to 4 nights. However, gentle methods generally require a bit more time.
When implementing any sleep training approach, it is crucial to maintain consistency. Teaching your child to fall asleep independently is akin to acquiring any new skill—it is normal to encounter a few setbacks before making progress. Step #1 is to redefine your child’s expectations regarding bedtime, while step #2 involves providing them with ample opportunities to practice and become adept at falling asleep on their own.
Sleep training methods for babies aged 1 year and older
We often receive inquiries about the best sleep training methods for older babies. Each method has its advantages and disadvantages and can be tailored to suit your family’s preferences. Here is a brief overview of some common sleep training approaches:
This approach emphasizes gradual changes. For instance, the fading technique involves substituting a feeding with rocking, then gradually reducing the amount of rocking before placing the baby in the crib while they are still awake. You would provide support and pat them to sleep if needed, gradually removing your presence as a sleep association. This method is favored by parents who want to minimize tears and are willing to invest more time in the process.
Parents often wonder if gentle sleep training is suitable for older babies or toddlers. The good news is that gradual approaches can still be effective, even though they may take longer to yield results. It can be challenging when you have an active child who prefers sitting or standing instead of lying down, but with patience and consistency, progress can be made.
The chair method is another gradual sleep training technique. In this method, you sit in a chair next to your child’s crib while they learn to fall asleep independently. Over time, you gradually move the chair farther away from the crib and closer to the door, maintaining your presence in the room but reducing direct contact. The goal is to stay in the room with your baby until they fall asleep, eventually reaching a point where your presence is no longer necessary for them to drift off.
This method is often used following the fading technique mentioned earlier. It is considered a gentle approach to gradually reduce your involvement in the sleep routine. However, some children may become more frustrated if you remain in the room without offering assistance, leading to tears and slower progress.
The popular Ferber method follows a “check and console” strategy. This method is preferred by caregivers who desire quicker results and are comfortable with allowing their babies to cry for defined periods of time until they fall asleep.
Rather than making gradual changes to your baby’s sleep habits, the Ferber method involves putting your baby in their crib while still awake after their bedtime routine and leaving the room. It is normal for your baby to cry at this stage since it may be unfamiliar to them. With the Ferber method, you start by leaving for short intervals and gradually increase the time between check-ins until your baby falls asleep.
Some view the Ferber method as a variation of “cry-it-out” (CIO) because it involves leaving the baby in their sleep space and allowing them to cry. However, unlike total extinction CIO, the parent usually returns at regular intervals to soothe the baby before leaving again. Some variations of this method may involve picking up the baby or staying in the room to provide comfort.
Cry it out
Cry-it-out (CIO) or total extinction is a fast-acting form of sleep training where the baby is allowed to fall asleep independently without any intervention or comfort measures. This approach is often considered a last resort for many parents due to the potential amount of crying involved. However, for some parents who find that check-ins to soothe their baby actually lead to more distress, this method may result in overall fewer tears.
When using this technique, you put your baby in the crib while they are awake after their bedtime routine, then leave the room without returning to calm them down when they protest. Some babies may fall asleep within 10 minutes, while others may cry for a longer duration.
Before attempting this strategy, it is crucial to ensure that your baby is adequately fed, dry, not in physical discomfort, and developmentally capable of self-soothing without support. For added safety, it is recommended to use a video monitor with hourly check-ins.
Sleep training tips for children aged 1 year and older
Tip #1: Determine the right bedtime
Establishing an appropriate bedtime can help minimize bedtime struggles. Babies who still take two naps a day generally require 3-4 hours of awake time before bedtime, while older babies and toddlers typically need 5-6 hours of awake time. You can use our Schedule Creator to find the optimal bedtime for your child.
Tip #2: Take breaks and reset
During the sleep training process, try not to rely on assisting your child to sleep. If your child is having difficulty falling asleep independently at bedtime, it’s okay to take a 15-minute break before trying again. Make sure to follow a shortened version of your bedtime routine to signal that it’s time for bed. This can help calm upset children and provide an opportunity for those with persistent temperaments to reset.
Tip #3: Minimize constant intervention
If your little one stands, sits, or plays in their crib during sleep time, remember that it’s a common occurrence. While it may be tempting to continuously lay them back down, doing so can result in a power struggle and lead to frustration for both of you. Instead, allow your child some space to wind down on their own. You can gently remind them every 10-15 minutes that it’s time to sleep and gently reposition them if needed.
Can you sleep train 1 year olds for naps?
Absolutely! If your baby still takes two naps per day, it’s possible that one nap may be skipped during daytime sleep training. Here are some tips to help you navigate the process:
– If your baby takes two naps, focus on each nap for an hour during sleep training.
– If your child takes only one nap, you may want to work on each nap for 90 minutes.
– If your child is struggling to fall asleep independently, take a break for an hour. Then, follow a shortened version of your naptime routine and try again. If your child still doesn’t nap after the second attempt, consider it skipped and move on.
You might need to adjust bedtime by around 30 minutes earlier if naps are shorter or skipped to prevent overtiredness.
How to sleep train 1 year old twins?
Here are some tips for sleep training twins during naptime:
– Temporarily separate the twins until their napping improves.
– Use white noise in the room to help mask sounds when they are napping together.
– If one twin wakes up early, wake the other twin within 15-30 minutes to keep their schedules in sync, making it easier to establish a consistent bedtime at night (optional).
What to do if sleep training your 1 year old is not working
Sleep training is a process that involves teaching your child new habits and skills. If you’re not seeing immediate progress, don’t get discouraged. Consider the following:
– Ensure that your baby is falling asleep independently each night. Inconsistency, with some nights involving assistance and others not, can create confusion and slow progress.
– Put your baby in their bed when they are more awake rather than excessively drowsy.
– Consult with your pediatrician to rule out any underlying medical issues.
– Consider getting a personalized sleep plan through Huckleberry Premium.
– Key takeaway for sleep training 1 year olds and older babies
Improving your child’s sleep requires patience and effort; there is no instant solution. If you choose to sleep train, remember that you have options. While there are different sleep training methods available, the most suitable one for your family depends on your specific circumstances, parenting style, and your child’s temperament.
Changing established habits can be challenging. If your child is accustomed to falling asleep with your assistance, anticipate some resistance when they are suddenly expected to fall asleep in a new way. With consistency and patience, they can learn new sleeping habits if that is your goal.
Sleep training babies 1 year olds and older FAQ
Q: Is it too late to sleep train a 1-year-old?
No, it is not too late to sleep train a 1-year-old. Sleep training can be effective for improving sleep habits in children of this age.
Q: Can you sleep train an older baby?
Yes, sleep training can be done for older babies. While it may take some time and adjustment, older babies can learn to fall asleep independently and develop healthy sleep habits.
Q: What is the best method of sleep training for older babies?
The best method of sleep training for older babies can vary depending on the child and family preferences. Some common methods include gradual techniques like fading or the chair method, as well as more direct approaches like the Ferber method or total extinction. The choice of method should consider the child’s temperament and the parent’s comfort level.
Q: Can you sleep train a 2-year-old?
Yes, sleep training can be applied to 2-year-olds. While older children may have more established sleep habits, they can still benefit from sleep training to promote independent sleep skills and better sleep patterns. It may require patience and consistency, but it is possible to sleep train a 2-year-old.
Q: How to sleep train 1-year-olds and older babies?
There are various methods available to teach your child to self-soothe and develop healthy sleep habits. These methods range from gradual approaches that minimize crying to faster methods that may involve more tears. Regardless of the method you choose, it serves as a foundation to help your baby learn to fall asleep independently.
Q: Is it too late to sleep train a 1-year-old?
No, it is never too late to establish new sleep habits. Although parents of older babies and toddlers may face additional challenges due to their increased mobility and independence-seeking behaviors, many parents have successfully improved sleep through sleep training at this age.
Q: How to sleep train 1+ year old babies without crying?
Many parents seek “no cry” sleep training methods. While a gradual approach can minimize tears, it is normal for children to feel upset during a routine change. While you can provide comfort during this transition, excessive intervention may hinder progress.
Q: Should babies aged 1+ year old fall asleep on their own?
While most children aged 12 months and older are capable of falling asleep independently, the decision to sleep train for improved bedtime, night sleep, and naps ultimately rests with the family.
Q: Which sleep training method is best for 1-year-olds and older babies?
There is no single “best” sleep training method for older babies and toddlers. The most suitable method for your family will depend on your child’s temperament, your goals and parenting style, and your ability to maintain consistency.
Q: Is it harder to sleep train 1+ year old babies?
At this age, children are typically ready to learn self-soothing techniques, although older babies and toddlers who are accustomed to falling asleep with assistance may pose additional challenges due to their mobility and independent nature.
Q: Can you let 1-year-olds and older babies cry it out?
Research suggests that graduated extinction methods can strengthen the parent-child bond, and there is no evidence that sleep training is harmful. However, if you choose to use the total extinction (cry-it-out) method, it is recommended to use a video monitor to ensure your child’s safety.